DBS vs reference checks in care — different risks, both required by CQC
A DBS check and an employment reference are not alternatives — they are complementary. DBS reveals criminal history. References reveal professional conduct. CQC Regulation 19 requires both precisely because a clear DBS says nothing about how a care worker has behaved with vulnerable adults in previous roles. From 99p per reference, no subscription.
The most important thing to understand: a clear DBS does not mean references are not needed in care
A DBS check reveals criminal conviction history. It cannot reveal professional safeguarding concerns handled internally by a previous employer. A care worker who was dismissed for inappropriate conduct with a service user — a matter resolved internally without police involvement — may have a completely clear DBS certificate. The only record of those concerns exists with the previous employer. The only way to access it is through a reference with explicit safeguarding questions.
DBS checks vs reference checks in care — what each one covers
Enhanced DBS Check
What it reveals
- Criminal convictions and cautions (spent and unspent)
- Whether on the adults barred list
- Whether on the children's barred list
- Police intelligence in some circumstances
What it cannot reveal
- Professional conduct with service users
- Internal disciplinary procedures not prosecuted
- Safeguarding concerns handled by previous employer
- Attendance, reliability and performance
- Whether the previous employer would re-employ
- Conduct concerns that never reached police
CQC Reference Check
What it reveals
- Suitability to work with vulnerable adults
- Conduct and behaviour with service users
- Disciplinary history including internal procedures
- Safeguarding concerns raised by previous employer
- Attendance, reliability and attitude
- Whether previous employer would re-employ
What it cannot reveal
- Criminal conviction history
- Whether on any barred list
- Offences not disclosed to the employer
- Police or court information
DBS vs reference checks in care — the complete guide
In the care sector, the assumption that a clear DBS check is sufficient evidence of a worker's suitability is one of the most dangerous misconceptions in recruitment. It is also one that CQC inspectors frequently encounter when reviewing recruitment files — and one that results in Regulation 19 findings.
Why CQC requires both checks
CQC Regulation 19 requires care providers to only employ staff who are fit and proper for their role. It specifies a range of pre-employment checks — including both an enhanced DBS check with barred list and employment references. These are not presented as alternatives. They are separate requirements because they address different risks.
The DBS system can only record what has been reported to it — criminal convictions, cautions and barring decisions. The entire category of professional misconduct that is handled internally — without police involvement, without prosecution, without a conviction — is invisible to the DBS. It is visible only to the previous employer. And the only way to access it is to ask, directly, through a structured written reference with explicit safeguarding and conduct questions.
The recruitment timing of DBS and references in care
Both checks must be complete before the care worker starts. Best practice — and CQC guidance — is to initiate references as early as possible in the process, ideally at application stage, so concerns can be explored with the candidate at interview. DBS checks are typically applied for once a conditional offer is made, as they require the candidate's cooperation and verification of identity documents. References should always be initiated first — they can be returned in 1 to 3 days through RefAssure and concerns identified before an offer is extended.
DBS vs reference checks in care — questions answered
A DBS check reveals criminal conviction history and barred list status. A reference reveals professional conduct — how the candidate has behaved with vulnerable adults in previous care roles. Both are required by CQC Regulation 19 because they cover entirely different safeguarding risks.
No. A clear DBS reveals no criminal record — it says nothing about professional conduct or internal disciplinary matters. A care worker dismissed for conduct concerns handled internally may have a clear DBS. Only a reference can reveal this. CQC requires both checks.
Internal disciplinary procedures, safeguarding concerns handled by previous employers, conduct concerns that never reached police, performance and reliability issues, and whether the previous employer would re-employ. None of this appears on any DBS certificate.
Both must be complete before the worker starts. Best practice is to initiate references at application stage so concerns can be explored at interview. DBS checks are typically applied for after a conditional offer. References should be initiated first as they return faster.
CQC requires all checks to be complete before a worker starts. There is a limited supervised start exception for delayed DBS results only — with documented risk assessment and barred list check. References must always be complete before a worker starts — no exception applies.
More CQC compliance guides
The reference check that DBS cannot replace.
From 99p.
CQC-compliant written references with safeguarding questions, candidate consent and full audit trail — the half of Regulation 19 that the DBS cannot do.
From 99p per reference · No monthly fees · Credits never expire · UK data hosting